7 Red Flags Your SaaS Marketing Agency Isn't Delivering Results (And What to Do About It)

Why Most SaaS Companies Miss These Marketing Agency Red Flags Until It's Too Late

You hired a marketing agency because you needed help. Maybe your in-house marketing team was stretched thin. Or you needed specialized expertise to crack the paid acquisition code. You did your research, sat through a few sales pitches, and finally signed on the dotted line.

Fast forward six months. Something feels... off.

The reports look pretty, sure. But your MRR isn't moving the way it should. Your CAC is still uncomfortably high. And when you ask pointed questions? You get vague answers wrapped in marketing jargon.

After working with companies like Mixpanel, ShipBob, and Originality.AI, we've learned that most SaaS founders don't realize they're working with the wrong agency until they've already burned through months of budget and missed critical growth windows. When we dig into what went wrong, the same patterns emerge. These common red flags were there from the begining. They just didn't know what to look for.

So let's talk about the warning signs that your current agency isn't delivering real results, and what you should actually do about it.

Red Flag #1: Lack of Transparency in Reporting and Communication

This is the big one.

Honestly, it's often the first domino that tips everything else over.

Your Agency Avoids Discussing Metrics That Matter to SaaS Growth

How many times have you stared at a monthly report full of impressive-looking charts that tell you absolutely nothing about revenue?

Impressions, clicks, CTR. Sure, those are all there. But where's the data on qualified leads? What about SQL-to-customer conversion rates?

When we started working with one SaaS client in the martech space, their previous agency had been sending monthly reports that looked impressive at first glance. Lots of charts. Very colorful. But when we asked to see how their Google Ads spend was impacting actual revenue? Nothing.

The agency had been optimizing for clicks, not customers.

That's not marketing. That's just burning money with extra steps.

Warning Signs: When "Trust Us" Replaces Data-Driven Insights

If your agency says "trust us, it's working" more often than they show you concrete proof, you've got a problem.

Real digital marketing agencies live and breathe in the data. At Aimers, we have an entire analytics team dedicated to tracking campaign performance (not because we're paranoid, but because we've learned that marketing rarely fails because of low traffic). The real leak is often deeper in the funnel. We don't guess. We track.

What Transparency Should Look Like in Digital Marketing Agencies

Real transparency means you can log into your accounts whenever you want. It means weekly or bi-weekly check-ins where actual strategists (not account managers reading from a script) walk you through what's working and what's not.

It means they tell you when something isn't performing before you have to ask.

What Transparency Should Look Like in Digital Marketing Agencies

We give our clients direct access to dashboards that show real-time performance across all their paid search and paid social campaigns. If an agency is hiding the data or making it hard to access, you have to wonder what they're trying to hide.

Red Flag #2: They're Using Cookie-Cutter Marketing Strategies That Don't Align With Your Goals

If your agency's strategy for your PLG SaaS company looks eerily similar to what they'd do for an e-commerce brand or a local service business, you've got a problem.

SaaS marketing isn't like other industries.

Your customer journey is longer. Your deals are higher value. You're asking them to integrate your solution into their workflow, possibly replace something they've used for years, and convince multiple stakeholders across different departments.

When we work with a new SaaS client, we start with a comprehensive audit of their entire paid acquisition setup to understand how their business actually works. What their sales cycle looks like. Who their best customers are. What makes someone convert from trial to paid.

This isn't rocket science, it's just doing the work that cookie-cutter agencies skip.

Red Flag #3: Your Current Agency Doesn't Understand SaaS-Specific Metrics

There's a canyon-sized difference between agencies that understand SaaS and agencies that say they understand SaaS.

Real SaaS expertise means they understand the economics of your business model. They know why a high CAC might actually be fine if your LTV is strong enough. They get why trial-to-paid conversion rates matter more than raw sign-up volume.

They can have an intelligent conversation about expansion revenue and net revenue retention.

If you want to understand these metrics better, David Skok's comprehensive guide to SaaS metrics breaks down everything from LTV:CAC ratios to cohort analysis, it's basically the bible for SaaS unit economics.

In the first 6 months, we increased the value of their sales opportunities from paid campaigns by over 60%. As we continued working together, that number grew to 4X overall.

That doesn't happen by accident.

Why Tracking Vanity Metrics Is a Major Red Flag

If your agency's reports are heavy on vanity metrics and light on business outcomes, that's your sign they're not equipped for SaaS marketing.

Vanity metrics are the stats that look good in a PowerPoint but don't correlate to revenue. We've seen agencies celebrate hitting 10,000 website visitors a month while the actual number of SQLs stayed flat.

HubSpot has a great breakdown of why vanity metrics are misleading and what to track instead.

Why Tracking Vanity Metrics Is a Major Red Flag

Did revenue go up? Did you acquire customers who'll stick around for years? No? Then what are we celebrating?

The agencies that truly understand SaaS focus on metrics that tie directly to your business goals: qualified pipeline, customer acquisition cost, payback period, trial conversion rates. The stuff that actually matters when you're trying to grow your business sustainably.

Red Flag #4: Communication Has Become Sporadic and Your Agency Isn't Responsive

You'd be surprised (honestly, you'd be shocked) at how many companies tolerate radio silence from their marketing partner.

If it takes your agency three days to respond to a Slack message, that's a problem. If they cancel meetings regularly, that's a problem.

If you have to chase them down to get updates on campaign performance? That's definitely a problem.

One of our clients told us their previous agency would go weeks without contact. They'd get their monthly report on the 15th, and then... crickets until the next month. No updates on tests they were running. No heads-up about budget pacing issues.

When clients tell us we feel like an integrated part of their own team (which is what Uppbeat's founder said about working with us), that's not because we're trying to win a personality contest. It's because consistent communication is table stakes for a successful agency partnership.

Your in-house marketing team doesn't go dark for weeks at a time, right?

Why would you accept that from an agency you're paying good money to?

Red Flag #5: The Promises Sound Too Good to Be True (Because They Are)

Do you remember when you were evaluating agencies and one of them promised to 10X your leads in 90 days? Or guaranteed first-page Google rankings across all your target keywords?

Yeah. About that.

How to Evaluate Agency Promises vs. Measurable Results

Any agency making guarantees about specific rankings or promising astronomical growth without understanding your current situation is waving a giant red flag.

Digital marketing doesn't work that way.

Search engines change their algorithms. Your competitors adjust their strategies. Market conditions shift.

The idea that any agency can guarantee specific outcomes? That's fantasy, not marketing.

Biggest Red Flags: Guaranteed Rankings and Overnight ROI Claims

The agencies making the biggest promises are often the ones least equipped to deliver measurable results. They're selling you on the outcome you want to hear, not the outcome they can actually deliver.

Biggest Red Flags: Guaranteed Rankings and Overnight ROI Claims

Real marketing agencies talk about process, not promises. They'll tell you what they've done for similar companies with case studies to back it up, what they think is possible based on your current state, and what realistic timelines look like.

When we started working with Originality.AI, we didn't promise them a 100% increase in Google Ads sales. We told them we'd audit their existing setup, identify opportunities, and systematically test improvements.

The 100% increase? That came from doing the work, not from making empty agency promises in a sales meeting.

Good agencies show you the path. Bad agencies sell you the destination without a map.

Red Flag #6: No Case Studies or Track Record With SaaS Businesses Like Yours

Simple test.

Ask your agency to show you case studies from SaaS companies they've worked with. Not testimonials. Not vague success stories. Actual case studies with specific numbers and outcomes.

Can't produce them? Or if their case studies are all from completely different industries? That should give you pause.

What to Look For When Choosing the Right Marketing Agency

SaaS marketing requires understanding subscription economics, long sales cycles, multiple touchpoints, and complex buying committees. An agency that's amazing at e-commerce might be completely lost in the SaaS world.

Look for case studies that show the initial challenge, the strategy they implemented, the measurable results they achieved, and ideally, the timeline. If you're trying to decide whether to hire a marketing agency, ask these questions upfront.

Red Flags to Watch: Testimonials Without Context or Real Results

A testimonial that says "Great to work with! Very responsive!" doesn't tell you anything about results.You need to know if they can actually drive outcomes.

When Mixpanel came to us, they needed to substantially increase their leads while driving down cost per lead. We focused on extremely detailed campaign management and analysis, constantly testing and optimising.

The result was exactly what they needed: more leads at a lower cost.

When an agency has done good work, they're proud to show it off with real data. When they haven't, you get warm fuzzy testimonials about "great communication" with no mention of actual performance, revenue impact, or return on investment.

Red Flag #7: Bad Marketing Agency Signs in Strategic Alignment and Goal-Setting

Your Marketing Agency Doesn't Understand Your Target Audience

If your agency is running campaigns without understanding who your customers actually are, you're in trouble.

We've seen agencies target "small businesses" for a product ideal for mid-market companies with 100+ employees. We've seen campaigns focused on features when the real selling point is the outcome.

This happens when agencies don't take the time to really understand your business.

The right approach involves customer interviews, analyzing your best customers to find patterns, and digging into your win/loss data to understand what actually drives buying decisions.

Even the best ad campaign can't save a broken landing page or misaligned messaging. We've seen companies spend thousands on Facebook Ads and LinkedIn Ads only to send traffic to landing pages that weren't built for conversion.

That's why we look at the entire funnel, from ad creative to landing page design to what happens after someone converts.

Agency Performance Issues: When Your Marketing Plan Doesn't Evolve With Your Business

SaaS companies change fast.

You launch new features. You pivot your ICP. You move upmarket or downmarket. Your pricing changes. You enter new verticals.

If your marketing agency's strategy looks the same today as it did six months ago, something's wrong. The marketing plan should grow and shift as your business does.

When ShipBob needed to adjust their targeting strategy, we didn't keep running the same campaigns, we reconsidered everything. The result was an increase in both lead volume and quality, plus better conversion rates across their top campaign groups.

That kind of strategic flexibility separates good agencies from mediocre ones.

When It's Time: A Strategic Framework for Switching Marketing Agencies

So you've read through these red flags to avoid and recognized more than a few.

Now what?

How to Know If Firing Your Marketing Agency Is the Right Move

Firing a marketing agency isn't a decision to make lightly. It's disruptive. It takes time to onboard a new agency. And honestly, sometimes the problem isn't the agency, sometimes it's misaligned expectations or unclear business goals.

But you need to seriously consider switching marketing agencies when:

How to Know If Firing Your Marketing Agency Is the Right Move

Entrepreneur has a practical guide on when to fire your marketing agency that covers the logistics and emotional aspects of making this decision.

Sometimes the right move is having a frank conversation with your current agency about what needs to change. But if you've already had that conversation multiple times and nothing's different? It's time to look elsewhere.

Finding the Right Fit: What Small Businesses and Growing SaaS Companies Should Look For

When you're looking for a new agency partner, here's what actually matters:

SaaS experience. Not just "we've worked with tech companies." Actual SaaS companies with subscription models and complex buyer journeys.

Transparent reporting. They should show you exactly how they track performance and give you direct access to your data. If they hedge on this, walk away.

Strategic thinking. You want strategists, not just tactical executors. There's a big difference between order-takers and strategic partners.

Cultural fit. You'll be working closely with this team. Chemistry matters more than people realize.

Steps to Take Before and After Switching to a New Agency Partner

Before you fire your current agency: Document all campaigns, logins, and account access. Download historical performance data. Make sure you own all your marketing assets (landing pages, ad accounts, creative assets). Review your contract for any termination requirements.

During the transition: Give your new agency complete transparency about what didn't work previously. Set clear expectations about communication, reporting, and goals. Don't expect immediate miracles, good agencies need time to audit, strategize, and implement.

After the switch: Establish regular check-in cadences right away. Define what success looks like in the first 90 days. Give them the time and space to do their best work, but also hold them accountable.

How to Find the Right Digital Marketing Agency That Delivers Real Value

Whether you work with us or someone else, what matters most is finding an agency that actually understands SaaS. One that's transparent about performance. One that focuses on the metrics that matter to your business.

One that acts like a true partner, not just a vendor checking boxes.

The right agency relationship can change everything. When you have a marketing partner who truly gets your business, who's as invested in your success as you are, who brings real strategic thinking to the table, that's when you stop worrying about whether your marketing is working and start focusing on bigger problems.

The wrong agency relationship?

That's just expensive frustration. Budget burned. Opportunities missed. Growth stalled.

Take a hard look at your current situation. Are you seeing these red flags? If so, it might be time for a change. In SaaS, momentum is everything. You can't afford to waste six months with an agency that's not moving the needle.

If you're wondering where your ad budget is silently leaking, or if you just want a second opinion on your current setup, we're here to help. We've spent over a decade working exclusively with SaaS and tech companies, and we know the difference between campaigns that look good and campaigns that actually drive revenue.

Book a strategy call with us and let's talk about your specific situation. No sales pitch. No pressure. Just an honest conversation about what's working, what's not, and whether we might be a good fit to help you grow. Sometimes a fresh perspective is all it takes to spot the leaks you've been missing.

Button Text

FAQs

How long should I wait before deciding my marketing agency isn't working out?

Give them at least 3-6 months, assuming you're spending a reasonable budget and they have access to what they need. Digital marketing campaigns need time to gather data, test, and optimize. That said, some red flags appear earlier. If you're seeing lack of transparency, poor communication, or they're clearly not understanding your business from day one, those are immediate concerns worth addressing. The 3-6 month window is for performance metrics to show improvement, not for basic professionalism.
Icon - Elements Webflow Library - BRIX Templates

What's the first thing I should do if I suspect my agency isn't performing well?

Start by documenting everything. What specific concerns do you have? Which metrics aren't moving? What promises were made versus what's being delivered? Then have a direct conversation with your agency about these concerns. Be specific about what's not working and give them a chance to explain or course-correct. Sometimes there are valid reasons for slow progress, like seasonal factors or necessary foundational work. But if their explanations don't make sense or nothing changes after the conversation, that tells you what you need to know.
Icon - Elements Webflow Library - BRIX Templates

Can I work with multiple marketing agencies at the same time?

Yes, and many larger SaaS companies do exactly this. It works best when each agency has a clearly defined specialty (one handles paid search, another does content marketing, etc.). The challenge is coordination, it requires more management overhead and clear communication to prevent overlap or conflicting strategies. For smaller companies with limited budgets, it's usually better to find one agency that can handle your core needs well rather than splitting resources across multiple partners. If your current agency can't do something, it might be worth finding a specialist for that specific channel rather than replacing them entirely.
Icon - Elements Webflow Library - BRIX Templates

What documents and access should I get from my agency before switching?

You need login credentials for everything: Google Ads, Facebook Ads, LinkedIn Campaign Manager, Google Analytics, Google Tag Manager, Search Console, and any other platforms they manage. Download all historical performance reports and campaign data. Get copies of all creative assets, landing pages, and any custom tracking or scripts they've implemented. Make sure you have admin access to all your social media accounts. Review who owns your website (if they built it) and get all the files. And don't forget your remarketing lists and audience segments, those are valuable and should transfer with you.
Icon - Elements Webflow Library - BRIX Templates

How much should I expect to pay for a good SaaS marketing agency?

This varies widely based on what you need and your ad spend, but expect to pay anywhere from $3,000 to $15,000+ per month for agency services, separate from your actual ad budget. Agencies charging significantly less often can't provide the level of strategic thinking and hands-on management that SaaS companies need. Agencies charging significantly more should be able to clearly justify that cost with specialized expertise and proven results. Generally, agency fees run about 10-20% of your ad spend, with minimums in place. The real question isn't what they cost, but what ROI they deliver. A $10,000/month agency that generates $100,000 in new MRR is a bargain. A $3,000/month agency that wastes your ad budget is expensive.
Icon - Elements Webflow Library - BRIX Templates

Join the community — Get Updates and Tips

Regular updates ensure that readers have access to fresh perspectives, making Poster a must-read.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By clicking “Accept all’, you agree to the use of all cookies. More information